DOI: https://doi.org/10.18523/2617-16782153219

Дослідження католицизму на сторінках журналу «Труды Киевской духовной академии» (1860-ті – початок 1900-х рр.)

Liudmyla Pastushenko

Анотація


У статті вперше здійснено цілісний та систематичний аналіз студій вихованців і викладачів Київської духовної академії, присвячених засадам віровчення, історії та тогочасному стану католицизму, що були надруковані в журналі «Труды Киевской духовной академии» починаючи з 1860-х рр. до початку 1900-х рр. Розглянуто основні проблеми, теми, ідеї, які стали предметом зацікавлення київських мислителів при вивченні цієї християнської конфесії, висвітлено специфіку підходу авторів статей до висвітлення та оцінки доктрини та літургіки, церковних подій Римо-католицької церкви. Виокремлено основні напрями досліджень католицизму та характерні риси цих напрямів. З’ясовано, що вивчення догматичних і канонічних положень католицизму мало полемічний та історико-критичний характер; у студіях з історії Римо-католицької церкви, чернечих орденів, біографій окремих визначних осіб в історії католицизму автори публікацій спиралися на величезний масив архівних документів та першоджерел; при огляді та оцінці тогочасного стану розвитку католицизму в європейських країнах православні автори виокремлювали основні проблеми та виклики, що стояли перед Римо-католицькою церквою у середині ХІХ – на початку ХХ ст.

Матеріал надійшов 16.09.2018


Ключові слова


журнал «Труды Киевской духовной академии»; Київська духовна академія (КДА); католицизм; Римо-католицька церква; Православна церква; догмат; богослужіння; чернечий орден; єзуїти; Папа Римський; церковно-державні взаємовідносини; поєднання церков; модернізм

Повний текст:

PDF

Посилання


Avgustin, arkhim. (1867). Polemicheskie sochineniya protiv latinyan, pisannye v Russkoy Tserkvi v XI i XII vekakh, v svyazi s obshchim istoricheskim izyskaniem otnositel’no raznostey mezhdu vostochnoy i zapadnoy Tserkov’yu [Polemic works against romans, hand-written in Russian Church in XI and XII centures, in connection with general historical research in relation to differences between East and Western Church]. Trudy Kievskoi dukhovnoi akademii, 6, 352–420, 9, 461–521 [in Russian].

Avgustin, arkhim. (1870). Spor grekov s latinyanami ob opresnokakh i kvasnom khlebe v tainstve evkharistii [Dispute of Greeks with Romans about leavened and unleavened bread in the mystery of Eucharist]. Trudy Kievskoi dukhovnoi akademii, 12, 645–670 [in Russian].

Bil’basov, V. (1871). Papissa Ioanna [The Pope-woman John]. Trudy Kievskoi dukhovnoi akademii, 1, 85–143 [in Russian].

Bulgakov, A. (1890). Fon-Dellinger, glava starokatolicheskogo dvizheniya [Fon-Dellinger, a head of the Old Catholicism movement]. Trudy Kievskoi dukhovnoi akademii, 7, 458–468 [in Russian].

Bulgakov, A. I. (1891). Bezbrachie dukhovenstva [Celibacy of clergy]. Trudy Kievskoi dukhovnoi akademii, 8, 578–605 [in Russian].

Bulgakov, A. I. (1898). Starokatolicheskoe bogosluzhenie [The Old Catholicism worship]. Trudy Kievskoi dukhovnoi akademii, 2, 249–287, 5, 130–152, 6, 298–310, 10, 179–207, 12, 590–610 [in Russian].

Bulgakov, A. I. (1899). Starokatolicheskoe bogosluzhenie [The Old Catholicism worship]. Trudy Kievskoi dukhovnoi akademii, 5, 43–78, 9, 53–78, 10, 219–231, 11, 414–446 [in Russian].

Bulgakov, A. I. (1900). Starokatolicheskoe bogosluzhenie [The Old Catholicism worship]. Trudy Kievskoi dukhovnoi akademii, 7, 335–381 [in Russian].

Bulgakov, A. (1903). Predpolozhenie o prinyatii eshche odnogo dogmata v rimsko-katolicheskuyu dogmatiku [Supposition about the acceptance of another dogma in the Catholic Curch dogmatics]. Trudy Kievskoi dukhovnoi akademii, 10, 149–171 [in Russian].

Bulgakov, A. I. (1905). Frantsuzskoe dukhovenstvo v kontse XVIII v. (v period revolyutsii) [French clergy in the end of 18th century (in the period of revolution)]. Trudy Kievskoi dukhovnoi akademii, 5, 10–28 [in Russian].

B., A. (1892). K voprosu o papskoy nepogreshimosti [To the question of the Pope infallibility]. Trudy Kievskoi dukhovnoi akademii, 3, 468–513 [in Russian].

B-v, A. (1891). Ideal obshchestvennoy zhizni, po opredeleniyu katolicheskogo, reformatskogo i lyuteranskogo veroispovedaniya [The Catholic, Reformed and Lutheran Church determinations of public life ideal]. Trudy Kievskoi dukhovnoi akademii, 9, 82–102 [in Russian].

B-v, A. (1893a). Iz zagranichnoy religioznoy zhizni [From foreign religious life]. Trudy Kievskoi dukhovnoi akademii, 3, 446–457, 5, 139–145, 6, 331–340, 7, 507–514, 8, 704–715, 9, 118–124, 10, 282–292, 11, 433–438, 12, 585–590 [in Russian].

B-v, A. (1893b). Katolichestvo v Anglii [Catholicism in England]. Trudy Kievskoi dukhovnoi akademii, 2, 261–279 [in Russian].

B-v, A. (1893c). Starokatolichestvo [Old Catholicism]. Trudy Kievskoi dukhovnoi akademii, 2, 280–289 [in Russian].

B-v, A. (1894). Iz zagranichnoy religioznoy zhizni [From foreign religious life]. Trudy Kievskoi dukhovnoi akademii, 1, 144–146, 2, 275–289, 3, 436–446, 4, 626–635, 10, 280–285, 11, 514–521, 12, 628–635 [in Russian].

B-v, A. (1895). Iz zagranichnoy religioznoy zhizni [From foreign religious life]. Trudy Kievskoi dukhovnoi akademii, 2, 350–358, 3, 497–507, 4, 659–670, 5, 139–149, 9, 159–169, 12, 680–692 [in Russian].

Bureha, V. V. (2016). Melkhisedek (Shtefanesku/Stefanesku Mykhailo). In M. L. Tkachuk & V. S. Briukhovetskyi (Eds.), Kyivska dukhovna akademiia v imenakh: 1819–1924 [Kyiv Theological Academy in names: 1819–1924]: encyclopedy in 2 vol. Vol. 2: L–Ya (pp. 171–174). Kyiv: Publishing house «KyievoMohylianska akademiia» [“Kyiv-Mohyla Academy”] [in Ukrainian].

Bureha, V. V. (2016). Petrov Mykola Ivanovych. In M. L. Tkachuk & V. S. Briukhovetskyi (Eds.), Kyivska dukhovna akademiia v imenakh: 1819–1924 [Kyiv Theological Academy in names: 1819–1924]: encyclopedy in 2 vol. Vol. 2: L–Ya (pp. 397–402). Kyiv: Publishing house “Kyievo-Mohylianska akademiia” [“Kyiv-Mohyla Academy”] [in Ukrainian].

Chetverikov, I. P. (1908). Religioznyy modernizm na zapade i bor’ba s nim rimskoy kurii (Po povodu entsikliki Piya Х “Pascendi dominici graegis”, 8 sentyabrya 1908 g.) [Religious modernism in the West and the struggle with it of the Roman curia (Concerning encyclical of Pius Х “Pascendi dominici graegis”, September 8, 1908)]. Trudy Kievskoi dukhovnoi akademii, 6, 320–354 [in Russian].

Chetyrkin, F. (1870). Latino-iezuitskaya propaganda v Konstantinopole v kontse XVI i nachale XVII stoletiya [Latin Jesuit propaganda in Constantinople in the late 16th and early 17th centuries.]. Trudy Kievskoi dukhovnoi akademii, 10, 82–126 [in Russian].

Dakhnovich, S. (1865). Iezuit Antoniy Possevin [Jesuit Antonio Possevino]. Trudy Kievskoi dukhovnoi akademii, 1, 103–138, 2, 229–276, 3, 373–418, 4, 506–555 [in Russian].

Fomenko K., prot. (1895). Vneshnyaya peremena onosheniy katolicheskogo dukhovenstva k pravoslavnomu na Vostoke [External change of relations of Сatholic clergy to Orthodox on East]. Trudy Kievskoi dukhovnoi akademii, 3, 492–497 [in Russian].

Gorodskiy, B. (1907). Ukloneniya i reforma rimsko-katolicheskogo kul’ta na zapade (Sv. Filomena; muzey chistilishcha, suevernye molitvy i blagochestie) [Deviations and reform of Catholic Church cult on the West (st. Filomena, museum of purgatory, superstitious prayers and holiness]. Trudy Kievskoi dukhovnoi akademii, 5, 64–88 [in Russian].

Holovashchenko, S. I. (2015a). Bulhakov Afanasii Ivanovych. In M. L. Tkachuk & V. S. Briukhovetskyi (Eds.), Kyivska dukhovna akademiia v imenakh: 1819–1924 [Kyiv Theological Academy in names: 1819–1924]: encyclopedy in 2 vol. Vol. 1: A–K (pp. 242–245). Kyiv: Publishing house “Kyievo-Mohylianska akademiia” [“Kyiv-Mohyla Academy”] [in Ukrainian].

Holovashchenko, S. I. (2015b). Irynei (Orda Kharysym Mykhailovych). In M. L. Tkachuk & V. S. Briukhovetskyi (Eds.), Kyivska dukhovna akademiia v imenakh: 1819–1924 [Kyiv Theological Academy in names: 1819–1924]: encyclopedy in 2 vol. Vol. 1: A–K (pp. 600–603). Kyiv: Publishing house “Kyievo-Mohylianska akademiia” [“Kyiv-Mohyla Academy”] [in Ukrainian].

Iudin, A. (Sost.). (2005). Pravoslavie i katolichestvo: ot konfrontatsii k dialogu. Khrestomatiia [Orthodoxy and Catholicism: from confrontation to dialogue]. 2-e izd. Moscow: Bibleiskobogoslovskii institut sv. apostola Andreia [in Russian].

Izvestiya s Zapada [News from the West]. (1864). Trudy Kievskoi dukhovnoi akademii, 1, 112–120 [in Russian].

Izvlechenie iz protokolov Soveta Kievskoy Dukhovnoy Akademii 14 iyunya 1876 goda [Extract from protocols of the Concil of the Kiev Theological Academy for June 14 1876]. (1876). Trudy Kievskoi dukhovnoi akademii, 12, 465–466 [in Russian].

Iz tserkovnoy khroniki Zapada [From the church chronicle of the West]. (1869). Trudy Kievskoi dukhovnoi akademii, 1, 134– 147, 2, 295–311 [in Russian].

Khoynatskiy, A. (1868a). Zapadno-russkie uniatskie chasoslovy, oktoikhi, triodi, trefologiony, ili anfologiony, mesyachnye minei i ustavy [West-Russian Greek Catholic Hours, oktois, triods, trefologions, or anfologions, month mantles i charters]. Trudy Kievskoi dukhovnoi akademii, 9, 468–518 [in Russian].

Khoynatskiy, A. (1868b). Zapadno-russkie uniatskie apostoly, evangeliya, psaltiri, irmologiony, molitvoslovy i akafistniki [WestRussian Greek Catholic apostles, gospels, psalteries, irmolions, prayer-books and akathists]. Trudy Kievskoi dukhovnoi akademii, 11, 210–244 [in Russian].

Khoynatskiy, A. (1868с). Osobennye uniatskie chinoposledovaniya, imeyushchie otnoshenie k trebniku [Special Greek Catholic rituals related to the trebnik]. Trudy Kievskoi dukhovnoi akademii, 6, 424–472, 8, 235–268 [in Russian].

Khoynatskiy, A. (1869). Latinskie tserkovnye pesnopistsy i ikh pesnopeniya v rimsko-katolicheskoy tserkvi sravnitel’no s pesnopistsami i pesnopeniyami tserkvi pravoslavnoy (k voprosu o predpolagaemom edinenii anglikanskoy tserkvi s pravoslavnoy) [Latin church songwriters and their hymns in the Catholic Church compared with the singers and hymns of the Orthodox Church]. Trudy Kievskoi dukhovnoi akademii, 10, 39–112 [in Russian].

Khoynatskiy, A. (1870). Rimsko-katolicheskie prazdniki, ikh istoriya, bogosluzhenie i obryady (ocherk iz liturgiki zapadnoy tserkvi sravnitel’no s bogosluzheniem i obryadami tserkvi pravoslavnoy) [Catholic holidays, their history, worship and rituals (an essay from the liturgy of the Western Church as compared with the worship and rites of the Orthodox Church]. Trudy Kievskoi dukhovnoi akademii, 1, 210–291 [in Russian].

Kiprianovich, F. (1877). Bruno, arkhiepiskop Kel’nskiy [Archbishop of Cologne Bruno]. Trudy Kievskoi dukhovnoi akademii, 3, 469–503, 5, 360–385 [in Russian].

Kuzmina, S. L. (2016a). Malyshevskyi Ivan Hnatovych. In M. L. Tkachuk & V. S. Briukhovetskyi (Eds.), Kyivska dukhovna akademiia v imenakh: 1819–1924 [Kyiv Theological Academy in names: 1819–1924]: encyclopedy in 2 vol. Vol. 2: L–Ya (pp. 133–136). Kyiv: Publishing house “Kyievo-Mohylianska akademiia” [“Kyiv-Mohyla Academy”] [in Ukrainian].

Kuzmina, S. L. (2016b). Yastrebov Mytrofan Pylypovych. In M. L. Tkachuk & V. S. Briukhovetskyi (Eds.), Kyivska dukhovna akademiia v imenakh: 1819–1924 [Kyiv Theological Academy in names: 1819–1924] : encyclopedy in 2 vol. Vol. 2: L–Ya (pp. 847–849). Kyiv: Publishing house “Kyievo-Mohylianska akademiia” [“Kyiv-Mohyla Academy”] [in Ukrainian].

Lebedev, M. (1868). Bossyuet, episkop Moskiy, i znachenie ego dlya katolicheskoy tserkvi vo Frantsii [Bossuet, Mosc bishop, and his value for Catholic Church in France]. Trudy Kievskoi dukhovnoi akademii, 1, 59–105, 4, 3–41 [in Russian].

Malyshevskiy, I. (1867). Dominikanets Yatsek (Iakinf, Hyacinthus) Odrovonzh, mnimyy apostol zemli russkoy [Dominican Jacek (Jakinf, Hyacinthus) Odrovonge, false apostle of the Russian land]. Trudy Kievskoi dukhovnoi akademii, 4, 25–80, 6, 421– 481, 8, 215–292 [in Russian].

Matseevich, L. (1870). Pol’skiy propovednik XVII veka, iezuit Foma Mlodzyanovskiy [Polish preacher of the XVII century, Jesuit Thomas Mlodzianovsky]. Trudy Kievskoi dukhovnoi akademii, 4, 108–153, 7, 155–272, 9, 501–534, 10, 3–81, 12, 457–566 [in Russian].

Matseevich, L. (1871). Pol’skiy propovednik XVII veka, iezuit Foma Mlodzyanovskiy [Polish preacher of the XVII century, Jesuit Thomas Mlodzianovsky]. Trudy Kievskoi dukhovnoi akademii, 4, 128–208 [in Russian].

Mel’khisedek, ep. (1884) Papizm i nastoyashchee polozhenie pravoslavnoy tserkvi v korolevstve Rumynskom [Papism and the present position of the Orthodox Church in the Kingdom of Romanian]. Trudy Kievskoi dukhovnoi akademii, 7, 357–430, 8, 545–582 [in Russian].

Nevskiy, M. (1862). Sovremennoe sostoyanie voprosa o soedinenii tserkvey – vostochnoy i zapadnoy [The current state of the question of the Eastern and Western Churches union]. Trudy Kievskoi dukhovnoi akademii, 7, 304–358, 8, 359–395 [in Russian].

Orda, Kh. (1864). Apologeticheskaya i polemicheskaya literatura na zapade protiv sochineniya Ernesta Renana “Vie de Jesus” [Apologetic and polemical literature in the West against the work of Ernest Renan “Vie de Jesus”]. Trudy Kievskoi dukhovnoi akademii, 9, 71–160 [in Russian].

Pastushenko, L. A. (2015). Voronov Oleksandr Dmitrovich. In M. L. Tkachuk & V. S. Briukhovetskyi (Eds.), Kyivska dukhovna akademiia v imenakh: 1819–1924 [Kyiv Theological Academy in names: 1819–1924]: encyclopedy in 2 vol. Vol. 1: A–K (pp. 332–334). Kyiv: Publishing house “Kyievo-Mohylianska akademiia” [“Kyiv-Mohyla Academy”] [in Ukrainian].

Petrov, N. (1868). Kratkie izvestiya o polozhenii bazilianskogo ordena i raznykh peremenakh v ego upravlenii ot 1772–1811 [Short news about position of Bazilian order and different changes in his management from 1772 till 1811]. Trudy Kievskoi dukhovnoi akademii, 7, 147–168, 10, 100–144, 11, 245– 302 [in Russian].

Petrov, N. (1869). O vodvorenii iezuitov v Ispanii i raspryakh ikh s dominikanami [About Jesuits settlement in Spain and their dissensions with the Dominicans]. Trudy Kievskoi dukhovnoi akademii, 3, 404–450 [in Russian].

Petrov, N. (1872). Ocherk istorii bazilianskogo ordena v byvshey Pol’she [An essay of Bazilian order in former Poland]. Trudy Kievskoi dukhovnoi akademii, 5, 428–494, 8, 373–436, 11, 343–409 [in Russian].

Petrov, N. (1870). Ocherk istorii bazilianskogo ordena v byvshey Pol’she [An essay of Bazilian order in former Poland]. Trudy Kievskoi dukhovnoi akademii, 2, 295–374, 5, 225–317, 6, 480– 554, 7, 118–189 [in Russian].

Petrov, N. (1870). Ocherk istorii bazilianskogo ordena v byvshey Pol’she [An essay of Bazilian order in former Poland]. Trudy Kievskoi dukhovnoi akademii, 1, 3–85, 2, 161–272 [in Russian].

P., I. (1892). Protiv lzheucheniya o vselenskom glavenstve Rimskoy tserkvi [Against a false doctrine about universal supremacy of the Catholic Church]. Trudy Kievskoi dukhovnoi akademii, 9, 142–162 [in Russian].

Rodnikov, V. P. (1909). Tserkov’ i gosudarstvo v novoy Italii (istoricheskiy ocherk) [A church and state are in new (historical essay)]. Trudy Kievskoi dukhovnoi akademii, 3, 371–388, 4, 580–600 [in Russian].

Shmorgunov, Z. (1862). Tridentskiy sobor [Trident Cathedral]. Trudy Kievskoi dukhovnoi akademii, 8, 437–470, 9, 41–87 [in Russian].

Shmorgunov, Z. (1862). Tridentskiy sobor [Trident Cathedral]. Trudy Kievskoi dukhovnoi akademii, 3, 237–266, 6, 137–172, 9, 1–61 [in Russian].

Sil’vestr, arkhim. (1874). Otvet pravoslavnogo na predlozhennuyu starokatolikami skhemu o svyatom Dukhe [Orthodox answer for the Old Catholic offered chart about saint Spirit]. Trudy Kievskoi dukhovnoi akademii, 8, 182–302 [in Russian].

Sil’vestr, arkhim. (1875а). Otvet pravoslavnogo na skhemu starokatolikov o dobrykh delakh [Orthodox answer for the Old Catholic offered chart about good works]. Trudy Kievskoi dukhovnoi akademii, 1, 8–78, 2, 167–213 [in Russian].

Sil’vestr, arkhim. (1875в). Otvet pravoslavnogo na skhemu starokatolikov o Presvyatoy Deve [Orthodox answer for the Old Catholic offered chart about the Blessed Virgin]. Trudy Kievskoi dukhovnoi akademii, 1, 1–7 [in Russian].

Sistematicheskiy ukazatel’ statey, pomeshchennykh v zhurnale “Trudy Kievskoy Dukhovnoy Akademii” za 1860–1904 gg [Systematic index of articles placed in the magazine “Trudy Kievskoi Dukhovnoi Akademii” after 1860–1904]. (1905). Kyiv: Tip. I. I. Gorbunova [in Russian].

Sistematicheskiy ukazatel’ statey, pomeshchennykh v zhurnale “Trudy Kievskoy Dukhovnoy Akademii” za 1905–1914 gg. [Systematic index of articles placed in the magazine “Trudy Imperatorskoi Kievskoi Dukhovnoi Akademii” after 1905–1914]. (1915). Kyiv: Tip. “Petr Barskiy v Kieve” [in Russian].

Tamborra, A. (2007). Katolicheskaia tserkov i russkoe pravoslavie. Dva veka protivostoianiia i dialoga [Catholic Church and Russian Orthodoxy. Two centuries of confrontation and dialogue]. Moscow: Bibleisko-bogoslovskii institut sv. apostola Andreia, 2007 [in Russian].

Tkachuk, M. L. (2015). Avhustyn (Hulianytskyi Andrii Fedorovych). In M. L. Tkachuk & V. S. Briukhovetskyi (Eds.), Kyivska dukhovna akademiia v imenakh: 1819–1924 [Kyiv Theological Academy in names: 1819–1924]: encyclopedy in 2 vol. Vol. 1: A–K (pp. 77–80). Kyiv: Publishing house “Kyievo-Mohylianska akademiia” [“Kyiv-Mohyla Academy”] [in Ukrainian].

Tkachuk, M. L. (2016a). Vypusknyky Kyivskoi dukhovnoi akademii (1823–1919). Dodatok 5. In M. L. Tkachuk & V. S. Briukhovetskyi (Eds.), Kyivska dukhovna akademiia v imenakh: 1819–1924 [Kyiv Theological Academy in names: 1819–1924]: encyclopedy in 2 vol. Vol. 2: L–Ya (pp. 881–951). Kyiv: Publishing house “Kyievo-Mohylianska akademiia” [“KyivMohyla Academy”] [in Ukrainian].

Tkachuk, M. L. (2016b). Malevanskyi Hryhorii Vasylovych. In M. L.Tkachuk & V. S. Briukhovetskyi (Eds.), Kyivska dukhovna akademiia v imenakh: 1819–1924 [Kyiv Theological Academy in names: 1819–1924]: encyclopedy in 2 vol. Vol. 2: L–Ya (pp. 130–131). Kyiv: Publishing house “Kyievo-Mohylianska akademiia” [“Kyiv-Mohyla Academy”] [in Ukrainian].

Tkachuk, M. L. (2016c). Matseievych Lev Stepanovych. In M. L. Tkachuk & V. S. Briukhovetskyi (Eds.), Kyivska dukhovna akademiia v imenakh: 1819–1924 [Kyiv Theological Academy in names: 1819–1924]: encyclopedy in 2 vol. Vol. 2: L–Ya (pp. 159–163). Kyiv: Publishing house “Kyievo-Mohylianska akademiia” [“Kyiv-Mohyla Academy”] [in Ukrainian].

Tkachuk, M. L. (2016d). Sylvestr (Malevanskyi). In M. L. Tkachuk & V. S. Briukhovetskyi (Eds.), Kyivska dukhovna akademiia v imenakh: 1819–1924 [Kyiv Theological Academy in names: 1819–1924]: encyclopedy in 2 vol. Vol. 2: L–Ya (pp. 546–550). Kyiv: Publishing house “Kyievo-Mohylianska akademiia” [“KyivMohyla Academy”] [in Ukrainian].

Tkachuk, M. L. (2016e). Chetverykov Ivan Pymenovych. In M. L. Tkachuk & V. S. Briukhovetskyi (Eds.), Kyivska dukhovna akademiia v imenakh: 1819–1924 [Kyiv Theological Academy in names: 1819–1924]: encyclopedy in 2 vol. Vol. 2: L–Ya (pp. 159–163). Kyiv: Publishing house “Kyievo-Mohylianska akademiia” [“Kyiv-Mohyla Academy”] [in Ukrainian].

Tkachuk, M. L. (2016d). Sylvestr (Malevanskyi). In M. L. Tkachuk & V. S. Briukhovetskyi (Eds.), Kyivska dukhovna akademiia v imenakh: 1819–1924 [Kyiv Theological Academy in names: 1819–1924]: encyclopedy in 2 vol. Vol. 2: L–Ya (pp. 796–802). Kyiv: Publishing house “Kyievo-Mohylianska akademiia” [“Kyiv-Mohyla Academy”] [in Ukrainian].

Tkachuk, M. L., Voloshyn, Yu. V. (2016). Khoinatskyi Andrii Fedorovych. In M. L. Tkachuk & V. S. Briukhovetskyi (Eds.), Kyivska dukhovna akademiia v imenakh: 1819–1924 [Kyiv Theological Academy in names: 1819–1924]: encyclopedy in 2 vol. Vol. 2: L–Ya (pp. 768–769). Kyiv: Publishing house “Kyievo-Mohylianska akademiia” [“Kyiv-Mohyla Academy”] [in Ukrainian].

Vzglyad katolika na proshedshee i nastoyashchee Bogosloviya [Catholic point of view on the past and present of Theology]. (1864). Trudy Kievskoi dukhovnoi akademii, 10, 191–214 [in Russian].

Voronov, A. (1862). O proiskhozhdenii svetskoy vlasti pap [About the origin of society power of the Popes]. Trudy Kievskoi dukhovnoi akademii, 1, 53–104, 2, 164–196 [in Russian].

V-nov, A. (1866). Zametki iz tserkovnoy zhizni Zapada [Notes from Western Church life]. Trudy Kievskoi dukhovnoi akademii, 6, 231–254 [in Russian].

Yastrebov, M. F. (1878). Ideya papskogo glavenstva, zashchishchaemaya na osnovanii bogosluzhebnykh knig pravoslavnoy tserkvi [The idea of the Pontifical supremacy, protected on the basis of the liturgical books of the Orthodox Church]. Trudy Kievskoi dukhovnoi akademii, 6, 531–564, 10, 3–38, 12, 451–494 [in Russian].

Yastrebov, M. F. (1881). Katolicheskiy dogmat o nepogreshimosti papy [The Catholic dogma of the infallibility of the Pope]. Trudy Kievskoi dukhovnoi akademii, 11, 289–328 [in Russian].

Yaremenko, M. V. (2016). Dakhnovich Stepan/Stefan Oleksandrovich. In M. L. Tkachuk & V. S. Briukhovetskyi (Eds.), Kyivska dukhovna akademiia v imenakh: 1819–1924 [Kyiv Theological Academy in names: 1819–1924]: encyclopedy in 2 vol. Vol. 1: A–K (pp. 431–432). Kyiv: Publishing house “Kyievo-Mohylianska akademiia” [“Kyiv-Mohyla Academy”] [in Ukrainian].

Zagranichnye zametki [Foreign notes]. (1868). Trudy Kievskoi dukhovnoi akademii, 4, 338–354, 6, 564–578, 7, 169–184, 8, 325– 347, 11, 303–354 [in Russian].






Copyright (c) 2018 Liudmyla Pastushenko

Creative Commons License
Ця робота ліцензована Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.